Malbec vs Shiraz: Which Red Wine Is Right for You?

3 min read

Key Takeaways

• Malbec is smooth, fruity, and approachable, with flavours of plum, blackberry, and cocoa, ideal for casual meals, grilled meats, and those new to red wine.
• Shiraz is bold, spicy, and full-bodied, featuring notes of dark berries, pepper, and liquorice perfect for hearty dishes like steak, BBQ, and rich sauces.
• Malbec pairs well with lean meats, mushrooms, and lightly spiced foods, while Shiraz excels with robust, smoky, or heavily seasoned meals.
• Choose based on your flavour preference or food pairing but if in doubt, try both and explore your personal favourite with a tasting night.

Malbec and Shiraz are two powerhouse reds beloved by wine lovers around the world. Both offer bold flavours, deep colour, and food-friendly character, but they’re far from interchangeable. Whether you're shopping for your next dinner party or looking to explore something new, understanding the differences between these two wines can help you choose the one that best suits your taste and occasion.

In this guide, we’ll compare Malbec and Shiraz by flavour, texture, food pairings, and when to serve them, so you can decide with confidence.

Main Differences Between Malbec and Shiraz?

While both wines are considered full-bodied reds, they have distinct characteristics shaped by their origin and grape profile.

• Malbec is known for its juicy dark fruit flavours (think plum and blackberry), medium to high tannins, and smooth texture. Originally from France, it's now closely associated with Argentina, where the high-altitude vineyards give it vibrant acidity and ripeness.
  
• Shiraz (known as Syrah in France) is most famously grown in Australia. It offers a fuller body, higher alcohol, and bold spice-driven flavours like black pepper, liquorice, and dark cherry. Australian Shiraz, in particular, is known for its rich, intense style.

How Does Malbec Taste Compared to Shiraz?

Malbec is typically smoother and softer, with flavours of plum, black cherry, and cocoa. Its tannins are present but more rounded, making it approachable for casual drinkers. Shiraz, on the other hand, is bolder and more assertive. Expect flavours of blackberry, liquorice, cloves, and a peppery finish. Its fuller body and higher alcohol content make it a richer experience, great for those who love intensity in a glass. So, if you're after smooth and juicy, go Malbec. If you're craving bold and spicy, reach for Shiraz.

Which Wine Pairs Better with Food?

 Both wines are excellent for food, but they shine with different styles of cuisine.

• Malbec pairs beautifully with lean grilled meats, roast chicken, and mushroom-based dishes. Its fruit-forward profile makes it great for charcuterie boards and even mildly spiced foods like empanadas or tacos.
  
• Shiraz thrives alongside hearty meals, think grilled steak, lamb, beef ribs, or spiced sausages. Its boldness can handle smoky barbecue, spice rubs, and rich, tomato-based sauces.
  

If you're serving a summer BBQ, go Shiraz. If it's a casual dinner with roast vegetables or grilled meats, Malbec might be your better match.

When Should You Choose Malbec Over Shiraz (and Vice Versa)?

 Here’s a simple breakdown:

• Choose Malbec if you prefer smoother, more fruit-forward reds with soft tannins. It’s great for casual gatherings or for those newer to red wine.
  
• Choose Shiraz if you enjoy bold, structured reds with spice and depth. It’s ideal for colder weather, robust meals, or fans of powerful flavours.

If you’re still unsure, why not try both? Hosting a tasting night with one of each is a great way to compare and find your personal favourite.

Malbec vs Shiraz in a Nutshell

Malbec and Shiraz both offer rich, satisfying red wine experiences, but they appeal to slightly different palates. Malbec is known for being smooth, juicy, and approachable, making it a great choice for those who enjoy fruit-forward reds with soft tannins. Shiraz, on the other hand, is bold, spicy, and powerful, ideal for wine lovers who prefer intensity and structure in the glass.

The best choice ultimately depends on what you're eating, the occasion, and your personal flavour preferences. At World Wine, we’ve curated a premium range of Malbec and Shiraz wines from trusted producers around the world. Need a hand selecting the right wine for your event or meal? Our team is happy to help reach out via our Contact Page for personalised recommendations.